5 Comments
User's avatar
David Roberts's avatar

John,

I think one effect of that passage is to make the current characters more "real" in comparison to the myth, moving from epic primordial time back to the "present," even if the present is 500 years ago.

Great close read! And a technique to keep in mind.

Best,

David

Expand full comment
John Halbrooks's avatar

That’s a great point, David. Mantel’s present tense and the logistics of daily life make for a startlingly real contrast with the unreality of the pseudo-history.

Expand full comment
Duncan Sayers's avatar

Is she hinting that much mythology is based around women’s role in man’s downfall (Eve, Pandora, […], Anne Boleyn etc.)

Expand full comment
Duncan Sayers's avatar

...and as you say, the misogynistic roots of that.

Expand full comment
John Halbrooks's avatar

Yes, I think that is certainly implied--the idea, as Chaucer’s Chaunticleer exclaims (and then mistranslates): “mulier est hominis confusio,” or “woman is man’s ruin.”

Expand full comment